Bananas Foster Cobbler Recipe - Pizzazzerie.com (2024)

Bananas Foster is my favorite dessert, hands-down! It’s also the inspiration behind this delicious Bananas Foster Cobbler Recipe!

Want to Save This Recipe?

Enter your email & I’ll send it to your inbox. Plus, get new recipes from me too!

See Also

Halloween Rice Krispie Treat Cake Recipe - Eating RichlySour Cream Coffee Cake Recipe | Gimme Some OvenCornbread Casserole RecipeBest Apple Cake With Raisins & Walnuts Recipe on Food52

By submitting this form, you consent to receive emails from Pizzazzerie.

Howdy, friends! So turns out that half of my Instagram followers are as obsessed with banana desserts as I am! I received so many messages when I posted the making of this Bananas Foster Cobbler recipe!

I made it multiple times until I could get the ratio of cinnamon, rum, and all the deliciousness justttt right. Hard job, huh?

I absolutely love New Orleans food, especially banana’s foster. The famous dessert originated in 1951 at Brennan’s restuarant on Bourbon Street.

I wanted to combine my love for this classic New Orlean’s dessert with an easy-to-make “feeds a crowd” recipe. This banana’s foster cobbler does the trick!

I know Banana’s Foster doesn’t have pecans on top, but that’s my addition because I love the crunch and nutty flavor it gives this cobbler! You can trade them for your favorite nut or leave off.

Bananas Foster Cobbler Tips

• Ripe bananas work best in this cobbler, just like when you make banana bread. Don’t wait for them to turn black now, but the riper they are, the sweeter they are.
• I have used 4 bananas each time I’ve made this recipe, but if you’re using a larger or smaller dish, adjust accordingly. Also, sometimes bananas are tiny or massive. You get the gist. You can’t mess this recipe up.
• There is dark rum baked into the filling and the topping. Hello! We go big around here. Now if you want, you can leave the rum out. Just know that it won’t be as “bananas foster-y” tasting. It’s also not that much rum to begin with, so I say leave it in under all circ*mstances. YOLO.
• For reference, I used Myers Dark Rum because I had it on hand, but I am sure any dark rum would do the trick.

I think serving it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream (or whipped topping) is sort of a requirement, but my husband wanted to note eating it with a spoon direct from the cobbler dish when it comes out of the oven is also an option. He’s obsessed with it, and I’m actually the banana fan in the house. Basically, this Bananas Foster recipe is a WINNER.

I always order Bananas Foster if I see it a menu, but making it at home sounds like it would be a bit of an ordeal. One in which I could potentially burn my house down so let’s all go with this easier route, yes?

You can leave out the pecans if you wish or try a different nut (I love walnuts too), but the pecans were so southern and fitting in this recipe!

If you want to try another favorite banana recipe, this banana pumpkin bread is sooo delicious! If it’s not fall, you’re still allowed to have pumpkin, P.S. This is so good year-round! Usually I think apple reigns supreme when it comes to cobblers and pies, but it’s about time bananas has its day!

If you want to get fancy, you could bake this bananas foster cobbler into ramekins for individual sized portions (just reduce cooking time), but I’m a big fan of ease.

I think it’s easier to bake it all at once and scoop into miniature serving dishes. Then your guests can go back for more and since it’s so delicious, they will be doing just that.

More Banana Recipes to Enjoy:

• The Best Blueberry Banana Bread
• Banana Walnut Crumb Cake